Nawaz-Zardari Meeting in London: Yeh tu wohi jaga hay, guzray thehy hum jahan say?


Many of us remember the ‘All Parties Conference in London’ in the July of 2007. Then it was supposedly an alliance of the democratic parties against the dictatorship. Many of us believed it; though I am sure there were ‘wise old people’ around who knew how to interpret all that gala affair – the real meaning behind the fancy words. But Much water has flown under the bridge since then. And hindsight is always 20/20. Now reflecting back, we can safely say that it was a’Grand Alliance of the Criminals and Crooks’ against the ‘people of Pakistan’

What was behind that grand alliance? It had an interesting troubled history. Sharif family – and what later became PMLN – had inherited the mantle of Gen. Zia’s barbaric regime. Zia and cohorts had hanged Bhutto; by the end 1980’s it was becoming obvious that despite all the machinations of military rulers, PPP and its hitherto charismatic leader, Benazir Bhutto (who later lost most of her charisma under the stink of corruption) was a force to reckon with, and would spring back to power sooner or later. Sharif’s were then cultivated as the ‘bulwark’ against the PPP, against its supposedly left of the center politics and possible revanchism by Benazir – whose father was hanged by Gen. Zia and Company.

Given these dynamics, Sharif’s were born in politics as ‘congenital enemies’ of Benazir Bhutto and PPP. And then, before the ‘democratic awakenings’ of 2007, they had no qualms about it. They inherited Gen. Zia’s mantle, accepted it obediently and faithfully, and played a huge role in reducing and containing PPP in Punjab. The decade of 1990’s was thus a period of ‘dirty fighting’ between the two political entities; descendants of ZA Bhutto represented by Benazir and political offsprings of Gen. Zia in the form of Sharifs and PMLN. Meaningful truce was thus not possible; it was not practical, it made no sense. Both sides tried fighting like two wild wrestlers, who push and pull, drag and scratch, kick and bleed each other in the hope of knocking out the other – out of the ring for ever. Rehman Malik lead investigations, in 1993-96 which have provided the bedrock to the ‘Panama Files’ and Senator Saifur Rehman’s hiring of international detectives to expose ‘SGS/Cotecna’ corruption of Benazir and Zardari that became famous as ‘Swiss Cases’ was all part of that belief that we will knock out the other out of politics – and will then rule for ever.

It did not happen. Something else happened. While both sides were kicked out of power twice, in a trilateral struggle for control between them and the military establishment. It was not what made their minds. At least the final crystallization of strategies, the final  realization of ‘what we should do’ came later. It was the arrival of ‘Gen. Musharraf’ on the horizon who instead of playing the old game of ‘bringing the other in’ thought of himself as a ‘messiah’. Benazir who welcomed Nawaz’s ouster and held out an ‘olive branch’ to Musharraf, tried her level best to rekindle her fortunes on the ‘misery of Sharifs’ but was rebuffed by Musharraf, who had ideas of his own and who went on creating a ‘third pole’ of politics through the Chaudhries and PMLQ.

Benazir, who had become, courtesy ‘Swiss Cases’ a ‘persona non grata’ in the west, finally landed in Washington, in early 2006, with the plea that ‘Musharraf is playing double games in Afghanistan; and I will serve American power more faithfully under the banner of democracy’. A quintessentially flawed and immoral plan, viciously supported by many in the media and civil society, that manifested itself in the form of Pakistan’s most infamous political deal: The NRO. But Benazir was less interested in joining Nawaz; her power base was Washington. But this credit goes to Nawaz that he persuaded her to create a common front against Musharraf – at least she created the optics. Till her death, she the astute politician, was not much impressed by Nawaz’s ‘common front’ theory. For her, all that was a ‘convenient for the time’ tactic to empower her. Nothing more than that. And she considered ‘lawyers movement’ Nawaz’s illegitimate baby financed from London.

But painful time in jail and the misery of solitude of Saroor Palace had convinced Nawaz that the real enemy is ‘Pakistan Army’. And if he collects Benazir, PPP and all others under a common banner of democracy (not that he cares an iota about it) against the army then they can together rule for ever. This mentality, this framework, this idea defined and fueled the Pakistani politics from 2007 onwards – and finally lead Nawaz to fall like a teenage girl in Modi’s tight embrace. Benazir died at the hands of ‘mysterious killers’ but Zardari who inherited her power, her politics, her everything continued with the deal. The politics of past nine years, often derided as the ‘muk mukka’ was essentially based on the principle that ‘together we survive’.

Occasional skirmishing was essential to fool the public, to give ‘masala’ to the media and to create impressions of ‘distinct political entities’ which is needed for the game of elections. But while it is always possible to fool the majority endlessly, the real challenge is to cheat, confuse and split what is called the ‘aware citizenry’. This also worked well initially – thanks to many in the media, legal community and civil society – but with the advent of Imran Khan’s PTI as the third entity of Pakistani politics, this became increasingly more and more cumbersome and more and more difficult. And by now almost all, who have some functioning brain cells or some molecules of integrity could see and spell out that Nawaz and Zardari could have different bodily forms, dress sense, tastes of cuisine or woman but they both represent the same pole of Pakistani politics.

But the million dollar question is: Will they be able to fool the ‘aware citizenry’ once again? True, the genie of ‘mammon’ is out in the air again,those who pleaded the virtues of NRO for saving democracy, those who described ‘lawyers movement’ as a ‘revolution’, those who demonized the 2014 movement against the rigging in elections as ‘attack on democracy’ and the ‘social media teams’ paid by national exchequer will again be assembled, marshaled and paraded to cry mantras of ‘democracy under attack’ but will they be able to fool countless young men and women again?

‘Yeh tu wohi jaga hay, guzray thehy hum jahan say’! Reflecting back, after nine year, on ‘All Parties Conference in London’ in July of 2007, we now know one fact for sure: it was many things but it was not for democracy. It was an ‘Alliance of the Crooks and Criminals’ against the best interests of the people of Pakistan. It was an arrangement to make few families more and more rich, powerful and politically entrenched. It was a conspiracy to stifle new political growth, a conspiracy against democracy in the name of democracy. It was ‘rape in the name of love’.

Will they be able to fool us again? Will they be able to distribute the goodies to split the public opinion again? Panama Files has landed upon them from the skies; its not  possible to sell this as an ‘establishment plan’. And thanks God, ‘khakhis’ are not visible any where, for their ‘brain waves’  are capable of causing more harm than good. Panama Files implicates both of them: the Doctor and his patient. Dr. Zardari, suffers from the same malaise, same pathology, same itch; how can he treat, put balm and bail out his ‘most desperate patient’?. This remains to be  seen. This moment is not a test for democracy; this is a test of our ‘common sense’.

Leave a Reply


  1. Whenever there is any case related to corruption or something that is not acceptable for Ego Masters of this country, they start blaming others. The evolving political culture of political blame game is a no surprise to any sane mind in this country. It reflects two things I) whenever something goes wrong, the so called monstrous politicians turned egoistic authoritarian, something big happens to divert public attention to provide them with ample time to think and plan for some other games that can only benefit them. 2) Despite unchallenged hard evidence like we have seen from Panama Leaks, the nation and its ruling elite are not willing to face the critical mirror of what went wrong and who should be blamed and how to change the vicious and vindictive culture into a viable system of political governance for the best of the people. Look at what happened in other countries like GB and Iceland and still happening. No body challenged Panama Leaks, no one ask for judicial commission, but government of Pakistan has its own way of strange stupid thinking. The deliberate evolution of corrupt political culture is the hallmark of Pakistan’s national political life. Question that comes to normal citizen of this country is what will happen after Nawaz’s demise? Who will play political roulette? But for me political disasters only happen in those countries and societies which are devoid of critical thinking and reasoning and most importantly having urge to rational change. The continued corrupt political culture and people who manage it cannot be the credible future tellers.

    Absolute power always corrupts and this is what is currently happening in Pakistan. Concentration of power in the hands of few has actually ruined political system of this country, where state institutions are not even left to be apolitical. This is political plaque that this country is facing and unless we find remedial actions for it, this country will be regressed. Those who grab the power through intrigues, political conspiracies, killings and large social-economic terrorism, do not foresee any exit to their hegemonic control and they are stick to it like termites.

    This is high time to think that those nations and societies that allows criminally indicted and most corrupt people to hold offices of power, governance cannot be viewed as a nation of moral values and honor. I believe that unless thinking minds of Pakistan will start any movement and activate their thoughts and energies for a political change, country is at critical crossroads for its own fragmentation and by its own so called monstrous political leaders. Every educated person should come out on street to ask questions from Prime Minister and ask him to respond. They have to think on how to end this tyranny? how to end the political cruelty into responsible democracy and not a democracy where only elections are held and afterwards authoritarians or corrupt egoistic rulers rein into institutions. For me it’s a political emergency and in order to avoid it, we need preparedness plan in order to come up with workable solutions and those who are trouble makers cannot be part of solutions. It is hard to expect that the Parliament will hold Nawaz Sharif accountable like the one did in British parliament. This also shows inefficiency of National Assembly and Senate that is so weak to provide workable democratic option for change.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.